Peter Pan Donut & Pastry Shop is an institution I've frequented for years. The variety of donuts is fantastic, and the prices are very reasonable. The only downsides are the cash-only policy and the long lines on weekends.

Donuts. EXCELLENT. Purchased a White Cream Coconut and Apple Crumb Donut which tasted outstanding. PETER PAN has some of the fluffiest and lightest not to mention the BEST Donuts around. RECOMMEND.

Finally came to this Brooklyn staple!! Overall pretty good! I liked the blueberry buttermilk cake donut a lot, but thought the glazed donut was decent but nothing special! Maybe that's my choice for choosing something regular shmegular. I liked the ambiance a lot, it's super cute inside. I will for sure come back to try other options. At this price point it's pretty tough to beat!

No review really needed. A greenpoint staple. Absolutely divine. Blueberry buttermilk donut is to die for. The only reason I'm saying 4 is cash only is annoying.

As a huge fan of donuts, Peter Pan has been on my radar for YEARS, but I somehow never got the chance to swing by until yesterday! I chose the original glazed (which I hear is a classic) and my partner picked the cookies and cream. The original glazed knocked it out of the park! One of the best I've ever had. The cookies and cream was good but had too many sprinkles that the frosting didn't shine as much as it could have. I wish they topped it with oreos instead. Staff was friendly, and we went late in the day, so no wait. Cute interior, I loved the green! Keep in mind cash only, but much more reasonably priced than other donut shops. Would definitely return!

Ordered: Old Fashioned Glazed Donut (~$2) Boston Creme Donut (~$2) Aya's take: It makes sense why Peter Pan is a local favorite and classic! Upon walking in, it was a bit crowded and chaotic but somehow the staff is efficiently taking orders and serving customers. Both donuts tasted very fresh, light, and not overly sweet which I tend to prefer. If you're in the area, do yourself a favor and stop by! Note: they are cash only.

Old school classic donut joint still doing it right over many years. I recently did a six mile run to Peter Pan so I could use it as an excuse to pick up an assortment of delicious donuts and bring it to the family for Memorial Day weekend. The price is right and a dozen were so cheap. Plus, it's also an old fashioned dinette to enjoy an egg cream and donut. Great service too. There was a line of people here the whole time which shows how popular it is.

This is my husband's favorite donut shop. When we lived in Queens Peter Pan was frequently visited. Now that we live outside the City, it's harder to get here. I happened to be in the area and stopped in for some donuts to surprise him with. I ordered a Cream Chocolate Sprinkle Donut, Toasted Coconut Donut, Honey Dip Donut, Boston Cream/ Bavarian Eclair Donut, Chocolate Frosted Donut with Sprinkles, and Chocolate Cake Donut. We loved them all as always. CASH ONLY !!!!!